4 minute read
Turning a garage into an ADU
Often the cheapest way to get a separate-feeling space, because the shell already exists. The two things that decide whether it works are whether your jurisdiction lets a detached garage hold a dwelling at all, and what happens to the parking you are removing.
Whether a detached garage can hold a dwelling depends on where you are
Arlington explicitly allows an accessory dwelling inside a detached accessory building such as a garage. Alexandria allows it. Fairfax does not, by administrative permit: the unit must sit wholly within the single-family house, so a detached garage is out unless a special permit is granted on a lot of at least two acres. Whether an attached garage counts as part of the house in Fairfax is not spelled out in § 4102.7.B and is worth a call to the zoning office.
Fairfax § 4102.7.B(2); Arlington ACZO § 12.9.2 · Read the sectionThe parking question is the one people forget
Converting a garage removes parking, and jurisdictions are allowed to make you replace it. The state law expressly permits a locality to require replacement of the main house’s required parking where building the unit eliminates it. Arlington already works this way: a lot with one off-street space must keep one, and a lot with none must create one. Alexandria requires no parking for an accessory dwelling at all. Worth checking before you assume the driveway is enough.
Va. Code § 15.2-2292.4(D)(2) · Read the sectionWhat the shell actually saves you, and what it does not
You save the foundation, the walls and the roof, which is a real saving. You usually do not save on insulation, because a garage rarely has any worth keeping; on the slab, which is often uninsulated and sometimes sloped to drain; on the ceiling, if the height is tight once a floor build-up and insulation go in; or on the header work needed where the garage door opening is closed up. Budget for those four and the number is realistic.
Where it works best
A detached garage set back from the house makes an unusually good unit — it already has separation, its own entrance, and often a decent footprint. An attached garage conversion is simpler and cheaper still, but it feels like part of the house rather than somewhere separate, which matters if the point is a degree of independence for whoever lives there.
Questions people ask
Do I have to replace the parking I lose?
Possibly. Va. Code § 15.2-2292.4(D)(2) allows a locality to require replacement of the primary dwelling’s required parking where an ADU eliminates it. Arlington requires you to keep one off-street space, or create one if you have none. Alexandria exempts accessory dwellings from parking requirements entirely.
Can I convert a detached garage in Fairfax County?
Not by administrative permit. Fairfax requires the accessory living unit to sit wholly within the single-family house, so a detached garage is only possible by special permit, and only on a lot of at least two acres.
Is a garage conversion much cheaper than building new?
Cheaper, but not as much as people expect. The shell saves you the foundation, walls and roof. It rarely saves you on insulation, the slab, ceiling height, or closing up the garage door opening, all of which need doing properly.
Is your garage a good candidate?
Some are and some really are not, and the difference is usually the slab, the ceiling height and what happens to your parking. Tell us where you are and we will tell you whether your jurisdiction allows it, what the conversion involves, and what it is likely to cost.
See what you can buildAnything here that quotes the law links to the section it came from, so you can read the original. Rules differ by jurisdiction — check what applies where you are. This is general information, not a determination about your property.